Carmella for Troy

Her deputy mayor talks down to the people who question her

Mayor Carmella Mantello's deputy, Seamus Donnelly, runs both sides of her new City Hall deal. When council members, the auditor, union workers and residents ask him questions, he goes after them instead, and the records say something different from his answers.

6 min read · published · updated

Jump to a section (6)
  1. He sits on both sides of her City Hall deal
  2. Asked who insures the building, he said the council member wanted taxpayers to pay
  3. Asked about the City’s savings, he called it a political charade
  4. Asked about a contract, he called the union a liar
  5. Asked about camera searches, he asked what the council wanted control of
  6. What the record shows

Seamus Donnelly is Mayor Carmella Mantello’s deputy mayor. He was her first appointment. At council meetings, he answers for her administration. He also runs the development corporation behind her new City Hall.

The City budgeted his pay at $100,000 for 2026. The 2027 budget he helped put together lists him at $118,450 now, an 18% raise in one year, and $122,004 next year. That is more than the mayor’s $95,000. In 2024 he started at $94,266.

When council members, the City Auditor, union workers and residents ask him questions, he goes after the person asking. He has called a council member’s question about the new City Hall’s insurance a push to make “taxpayers pay.” He called the auditor’s budget questions “a political charade,” residents in the audience “cronies,” and a union officer’s statement “a lie.”

Each time, the records behind the question say something different from his answer.

  1. 2026

    1. Asked about Flock camera search logs, he asks what "control" the council wants.See the record — Asked about Flock camera search logs, he asks what "control" the council wants.

    2. He calls a union officer's statement "a lie."See the record — He calls a union officer's statement "a lie."

    3. He calls the City Auditor's questions "a political charade."See the record — He calls the City Auditor's questions "a political charade."

    4. A resident asks the council to remove him from the chambers.See the record — A resident asks the council to remove him from the chambers.

    5. Asked who insures the new City Hall, he says the council member wants taxpayers to pay.See the record — Asked who insures the new City Hall, he says the council member wants taxpayers to pay.

    6. He posts that the new City Hall saved taxpayer dollars.See the record — He posts that the new City Hall saved taxpayer dollars.

He sits on both sides of her City Hall deal

City Hall is moving into the old Proctor’s Theatre. The City will pay rent to the Troy Local Development Corporation, which bought the building, borrowed the money to rebuild it and collects the rent. The deputy mayor is that corporation’s chief executive and a voting member of its board. It pays him $20,000 a year on top of his City salary, up from $10,000. He did not vote on his own pay.

On May 29, 2025, the City gave notice it would leave its River Street offices, and he was copied on the letter. The next day he signed the Proctor’s deal as the development corporation’s chief executive. The mayor signed for the City.

Council Member Tom Casey sat on the same board. He resigned in July 2025 so there would be “no misconceptions of impropriety.” The deputy mayor stayed on. He told WAMC he sees no conflict because he is appointed, not elected. On November 12, 2026, he thanked people for the project “as deputy mayor and Troy Local Development Corp. executive director.”

The charts he used to sell the deal left out most of what the City will pay. The full numbers are here.

Asked who insures the building, he said the council member wanted taxpayers to pay

Council Member Noreen McKee also sits on the development corporation’s board. At a budget hearing on November 12, 2026, she asked where the insurance for the new City Hall is in the budget, and how much it costs. He said the development corporation would pay it. She asked how that fits the lease.

I understand that you’ve continued to advocate for taxpayers to pay the pay for that. … You are advocating to pass along that cost to taxpayers. … It’s not a traditional triple net lease. … I know you really want that charge to be relayed to the taxpayer.

Deputy Mayor Seamus DonnellyCity Council budget hearing, November 12, 2026, 1:21:21 to 1:22:48See the recordDeputy Mayor Seamus Donnelly, City Council budget hearing, November 12, 2026, 1:21:21 to 1:22:48

McKee answered that she was asking about facts: “It’s not even an opinion.”

The lease he sent the council says the City carries the insurance. Section 6.01 says the City “shall be responsible to pay taxes, utilities, insurance and maintenance and repairs” on top of the rent. The night the council approved it, he said, “We are in a triple net lease.” Asked for the insurance cost, he said, “I’d have to get back to you on that exact number.”

Earlier at the same hearing, Council President Sue Steele asked how the City’s crew would care for the new building. He talked over her and told her, “I know you don’t want to believe that.” She thanked him and said she hoped to “someday be able to ask a question without being interrupted.”

Asked about the City’s savings, he called it a political charade

On October 15, 2026, the City Auditor, who works for the council, asked about the City’s reserve funds. He cited the City’s own outside auditor, Bonadio. The deputy mayor first said the administration “did not come here prepared to answer” questions about the audited financial report. Then he asked the auditor, “Are you aware how to digest those documents?”

This is a political charade what’s going on right now. We have been more than happy to answer, okay? And your five supporters can snicker back there. … Your cronies can laugh behind me. … This is turning into a sideshow.

Deputy Mayor Seamus DonnellyCity Council budget hearing, October 15, 2026, 1:03:01See the recordDeputy Mayor Seamus Donnelly, City Council budget hearing, October 15, 2026, 1:03:01

Steele stopped him: “Seamus, stop. Right now.” After the auditor finished, the deputy mayor told him he “clearly” did not “understand how to read” the financial report.

A week later, a resident asked the council to act.

I urge you, Council President Steel, to remove the deputy mayor from the council chambers when he chooses to engage in these belligerent tirades.

Resident, public forumCity Council meeting, October 22, 2026, 2:50:42See the recordResident, public forum, City Council meeting, October 22, 2026, 2:50:42

Asked about a contract, he called the union a liar

On April 23, 2026, the union for City workers told the council its full contract was still unsigned. It also said the deputy mayor had talked to workers about their raises directly instead of through the union. When it was his turn, he said:

Comes here and says, “We don’t have a signed agreement.” Lie. That’s a lie. Of course we have a signed agreement.

Deputy Mayor Seamus DonnellyCity Council Law Committee, April 23, 2026, 0:32:08See the recordDeputy Mayor Seamus Donnelly, City Council Law Committee, April 23, 2026, 0:32:08

He was pointing to a shorter agreement signed in October 2025. The union was talking about the full contract, which was not signed. On talking to workers about raises, he called himself “the COO of our city” and said he was “totally allowed” to.

Asked about camera searches, he asked what the council wanted control of

On March 19, 2026, the council asked about Flock, the company whose cameras photograph every car that drives past them. McKee asked whether the council could review the police department’s search logs. He asked her what “control” that would give her.

I get using words like safeguards and stuff. I’m actually asking in actuality… I’m trying to understand what information you would garner from that to provide the safeguarding that you are looking for.

Deputy Mayor Seamus DonnellyCity Council committee night, March 19, 2026, 3:19:16See the recordDeputy Mayor Seamus Donnelly, City Council committee night, March 19, 2026, 3:19:16

When a council member said residents feared a stalker could get photos of their car, he answered, “I’ve never been a stalker, so I don’t know.”

The logs McKee asked about were later released through a records request. They show 5,309 outside agencies searching Troy’s data, 12 of them federal.

During public comment that night, a resident at the podium stopped mid-statement and turned to him in the doorway: “He started heckling me from the hallway. … I’m entitled to the same respect that you demanded when you were up earlier.” Twelve minutes later, another speaker turned to him: “Excuse me, Seamus. I’d like my time.”

What the record shows

The mayor’s deputy runs the development corporation that collects the City’s rent on her new City Hall, and he signed the deal for it. Asked who pays the insurance, he said the council member wanted taxpayers to pay, though the lease he sent the council says the City does. Asked about the City’s savings, he called it a political charade and called residents cronies. Asked about a contract, he called a union officer’s statement a lie, though the two were talking about different documents. Asked about camera searches, he asked what control the council wanted, and the logs later showed 5,309 outside agencies searching.

Sources

  1. Deputy Mayor Seamus Donnelly, Facebook post on the Proctor's walkthrough — Seamus Donnelly, Facebook (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Posted November 12, 2026. He thanks people for the project "as deputy mayor and Troy Local Development Corp. executive director."

  2. Ordinance 54 memo from Deputy Mayor Seamus Donnelly, with the proposed Proctor's lease — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Lease section 6.01, PDF p. 17: "The Base Rent is a triple net figure and in addition to the Base Rent the City shall be responsible to pay taxes, utilities, insurance and maintenance and repairs." Section 9.01, PDF p. 24: the City carries all-risk casualty insurance on the building.

  3. Proctor's City Hall letter of intent, May 30, 2025 — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Signed by Seamus Donnelly as Chief Executive Officer of the Troy Local Development Corporation, and by the mayor for the City (p. 8).

  4. Termination of Lease letter for 433 River Street, May 29, 2025 — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Copied to "Seamus Donnelly, Deputy Mayor" (p. 2).

  5. Troy Local Development Corporation minutes and resolutions, March 28, 2025 — Troy Local Development Corporation (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Names him "Chief Executive Officer and Executive Director of TLDC effective January 1, 2025" at $10,000 a year (PDF p. 12). He is a voting board member and abstained on his own appointment (PDF p. 2).

  6. Troy Local Development Corporation agenda packet, March 20, 2026 — Troy Local Development Corporation (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    The February 20, 2026 minutes say "in December, the executive director's amount was increased to $20,000," and that he abstained.

  7. Troy councilman quitting LDC to avoid conflict — Times Union (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    July 27, 2025. Council Member Tom Casey resigned from the development corporation board.

  8. Troy residents still seek more details regarding the proposed City Hall relocation — WAMC (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Reports that the deputy mayor sees no conflict of interest because he is appointed, not elected.

  9. Troy City Council meeting, November 6, 2025 — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    "We are in a triple net lease" at 3:03:05. Quotation from the recording's automatic captions, checked against the video.

  10. Troy City Council budget hearing, November 12, 2026 — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Council President Steele at about 1:16:23. The deputy mayor and Council Member Noreen McKee on Proctor's insurance, 1:20:29 to 1:23:14. Quotations are from this site's speech-to-text of the recording, checked against the video.

  11. Troy City Council Special Meeting and Finance Committee budget hearing, October 15, 2026 — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    The City Auditor's questions from about 0:55:00, citing the City's outside auditor, Bonadio. The deputy mayor at 0:59:51, 1:00:14, 1:03:01, 1:03:18, 1:03:37 and 1:05:33. Council President Sue Steele at 1:03:48. The YouTube captions, the meeting's own captions and a second transcript agree on these lines.

  12. Troy City Council meeting, October 22, 2026 — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Public forum at 2:50:42. Quotation from the recording's automatic captions, checked against the video.

  13. Troy City Council Law Committee, April 23, 2026 — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    The union on direct dealing at 0:21:45. The deputy mayor from 0:27:08, including the memorandum of agreement at 0:28:01, "the COO of our city" at 0:29:44, and "Lie. That's a lie" at 0:32:08. Quotations are from the recording's automatic captions, checked against the video.

  14. Troy City Council committee night, March 19, 2026 — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    The deputy mayor on stalkers at 3:13:49 to 3:14:35, and on Council Member McKee's audit-log question at 3:18:32 and 3:19:16. Public comment about him at 4:04:01, 4:16:25, 4:57:51 and 5:04:12. Quotations are from the recording's automatic captions, checked against the video.

  15. City of Troy 2027 Proposed Budget — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Printed p. 27, PDF p. 32. Deputy Mayor at a current salary of $118,450, rising to $122,004 for 2027. Mayor at $95,000.

  16. City of Troy 2026 Adopted Budget — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Printed p. 30, PDF p. 35. Deputy Mayor at a current salary of $99,266, with $100,000 recommended for 2026. From $100,000 to $118,450 is an 18% raise. The file is a scan with no text, and the figures were read from the page image. Council Member Jona Favreau raised the "18% increase" at the October 15, 2026 budget hearing (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K7vr24h6Nac&t=4266s).

  17. City of Troy 2024 Adopted Budget — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Deputy Mayor at $94,266. The 2025 Adopted Budget (https://www.troyny.gov/ArchiveCenter/ViewFile/Item/1343, PDF p. 29) lists $99,266.

  18. Troy's mayor-elect chooses her team — CBS6 (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    November 20, 2023. Names him as her first appointment.