Carmella for Troy

Mayor Carmella decides who gets a city job, and no rule says how

Mayor Carmella Mantello froze hiring for every Troy job outside police and fire, and says she will still hire "the right person" case by case. The council gets no say. Her deputy mayor got an 18% raise, and his cousin moved into a City job.

6 min read · published

Jump to a section (6)
  1. She froze hiring and kept the exceptions for her office
  2. “The right person” is a choice, not a rule
  3. The council gets no say
  4. Which jobs got through
  5. The people around her have done well
  6. What the record shows

Mayor Carmella Mantello has frozen hiring for every Troy city job outside police and fire. She says she will still hire “the right person,” case by case.

Her administration decides who that is. When the City Council asked whether it would approve those hires, her deputy mayor said it would hear about them only if the money ran out.

While 51 city jobs sit empty, the people closest to her have done well. Her deputy mayor got an 18% raise in one year. Her budget pays for a new secretary for him. His cousin, who lost her council job in January, now runs the City’s purchasing.

  • City jobs left empty in her next budget

    51

    Most in parks, code enforcement, water and sewer

  • Her deputy mayor's raise in one year

    18%

    $100,000 to $118,450

  • New pay for the deputy mayor's secretary

    $43,260

    A job no one is paid for now

City of Troy 2026 and 2027 budgets.
  1. 2024

    1. The mayor signs a $50,000 part-time job for the engineer leaving his City job.See the record — The mayor signs a $50,000 part-time job for the engineer leaving his City job.

  2. 2025

    2026

    1. The new council names a new City Clerk, replacing the deputy mayor's cousin.See the record — The new council names a new City Clerk, replacing the deputy mayor's cousin.

    2. City bid notices list the cousin as its purchasing contact.See the record — City bid notices list the cousin as its purchasing contact.

    3. The City pauses hiring outside police and fire.See the record — The City pauses hiring outside police and fire.

    4. At the first budget hearing, the mayor says new hires will be looked at "on a case-by-case basis."See the record — At the first budget hearing, the mayor says new hires will be looked at "on a case-by-case basis."

    5. The mayor says she will hire "the right person" during the pause.See the record — The mayor says she will hire "the right person" during the pause.

    6. The mayor says the planning commissioner's pay could go up for "the right person."See the record — The mayor says the planning commissioner's pay could go up for "the right person."

    7. Asked if the council approves those hires, the deputy mayor says only if the money runs out.See the record — Asked if the council approves those hires, the deputy mayor says only if the money runs out.

She froze hiring and kept the exceptions for her office

On October 8, 2026, the City stopped hiring for every job outside police and fire, “effective immediately.” Her budget message says how exceptions will work:

I have directed City departments and staff to pause hiring for positions outside of police officers and firefighters, while evaluating any potential new hires on a case-by-case basis.

Mayor Carmella Mantello2027 proposed budget messageSee the recordMayor Carmella Mantello, 2027 proposed budget message

“The right person” is a choice, not a rule

Every city job already has to go to someone qualified. Most are filled from a ranked civil service list: people take a test, and the City must hire from the top three names. At a budget hearing, she said the City would still hire “the right” person during the pause.

Obviously if the right mechanic does come along, we’re willing to hire he or she even though we’re on a pause. We talked about that case by case basis … we just haven’t found the right person.

Mayor Carmella MantelloCity Council Public Utilities budget hearing, October 29, 2026, 1:46:14See the recordMayor Carmella Mantello, City Council Public Utilities budget hearing, October 29, 2026, 1:46:14

She said the same at the first budget hearing, on October 15.

You really have to find the right fit. We’re not hiring just to hire. You’re going to see positions in here that haven’t been filled. … We’re really trying to find the right fit.

Mayor Carmella MantelloCity Council Finance Committee budget hearing, October 15, 2026, 1:47:21See the recordMayor Carmella Mantello, City Council Finance Committee budget hearing, October 15, 2026, 1:47:21

Qualified is the floor the law already sets. “Right” is whatever her administration decides it means.

At the Planning hearing on November 10, the City had gone about a year without a commissioner of planning, and one planner job had been empty since March. Asked about filling them, the administration gave the same answer.

As we’ve talked about in every department, yes, they’re on pause. But we are looking case by case. So if we find the right person for what we’re looking for, we will consider filling that position.

Deputy Mayor Seamus DonnellyCity Council Planning budget hearing, November 10, 2026, 0:19:10See the recordDeputy Mayor Seamus Donnelly, City Council Planning budget hearing, November 10, 2026, 0:19:10

The pay is not set either. The commissioner job is budgeted at $98,000. Asked why no one had been hired, the mayor said the pay could rise for the right pick.

We have done a couple interviews, received a few resumes, but just not the right person. … If we found the right person, we could potentially go up.

Mayor Carmella MantelloCity Council Planning budget hearing, November 10, 2026, 0:27:04See the recordMayor Carmella Mantello, City Council Planning budget hearing, November 10, 2026, 0:27:04

The council gets no say

On November 12, Council Member Greg Campbell-Cohen asked whether the council would need to approve each hire into an empty job. The deputy mayor did not say yes. He said the administration would come to the council only if the money set aside for empty jobs ran out and it needed a transfer.

There has been a pause and that you do see those vacancies paused. If we make our way through the year and there is not salary savings and we wanted a higher position, yes we would have to come to you for a transfer to fund that.

Deputy Mayor Seamus DonnellyCity Council General Services budget hearing, November 12, 2026, 0:45:27See the recordDeputy Mayor Seamus Donnelly, City Council General Services budget hearing, November 12, 2026, 0:45:27

Which jobs got through

The same hearings show which jobs make it past the pause, and which don’t:

  • Open and paid more: the deputy city engineer job, empty last year and this year, goes from $90,000 to $105,000. It is one of the “case by case” positions.
  • Filled just before the pause: a new deputy comptroller, who started about three weeks before the October 15 hearing. A council member put the pay at more than $100,000. The comptroller called it a recent hire on October 22.
  • Paid for the first time: a private secretary to the deputy mayor at $43,260. No one is paid in that job now.
  • Put off to the end of 2027: five of the City’s laborers, the sign crew, water plant workers, water main crews, and a full-time City lawyer.

The people around her have done well

Her deputy mayor. Seamus Donnelly started in 2024 at $94,266. Her 2026 budget set his pay at $100,000. Her 2027 budget lists him at $118,450 now, an 18% raise in one year, and $122,004 next year. The mayor’s own pay is $95,000. He also runs the development corporation behind her new City Hall. See how he answers the people who question her.

Most city workers outside police and fire can’t afford a typical Troy apartment on their own pay. See city pay against Troy rent.

His cousin. Maria DeBonis is the deputy mayor’s cousin. The council appointed her City Clerk in 2024. In August 2025 she spoke for the mayor’s City Hall plan. In January 2026 the new council named a different clerk. By March 2026 she was the City’s Purchasing Agent, the job that runs the City’s bids. On November 12 he thanked “Purchasing Agent Maria DeBonis” for the new City Hall.

Her city engineer. In December 2024, Russ Reeves stopped being paid as City Engineer. The mayor signed a form giving him a $50,000 part-time job running the water department. After he left the payroll, he wrote one of her emergency demolition reports on his own firm’s paper and billed the City $3,415. The full record is here.

The people who disagree with her get different treatment. Her administration has called them liars and paranoid. Read how she treats them.

What the record shows

The mayor froze hiring for every job outside police and fire, and said she would still hire “the right person,” case by case. For one job, she said the right person could also get more pay. Every city job already has to go to someone qualified. Asked whether the council approves those hires, her deputy mayor said it would hear about them only if the money ran out. Her budget raises her deputy mayor’s pay 18% in a year and pays for his new secretary, while laborers and water workers wait until the end of 2027. His cousin became the City’s Purchasing Agent after the council replaced her as clerk.

Sources

  1. City of Troy 2027 Proposed Budget — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Mayor's message, PDF p. 8: the hiring pause and "case-by-case" exceptions. Printed p. 27, PDF p. 32: Deputy Mayor at a current salary of $118,450, $122,004 for 2027; Private Secretary to the Deputy Mayor at $0 now and $43,260 for 2027. Law Department, PDF p. 59 area: Deputy Corporation Counsel (full time) at $0 now and $87,524 for 2027.

  2. Troy mayor institutes hiring freeze — Times Union (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    October 8, 2026. Quotes the memo, "We are instituting a pause in hiring of all positions outside of police officers and firefighters, effective immediately."

  3. Troy City Council Public Utilities budget hearing, October 29, 2026 — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    The mayor on "the right mechanic" at 1:46:14 and 1:56:59. Water plant jobs deferred to the end of 2027 at 2:13:50, water main jobs at 2:22:31. Quotations from this site's speech-to-text of the recording, checked against the video.

  4. Troy City Council General Services budget hearing, November 12, 2026 — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Council Member Greg Campbell-Cohen on council approval of hires at 0:44:57, and the deputy mayor's answer at 0:45:16 to 0:45:50. Deputy city engineer at 0:52:20, "case by case" at 0:53:27. Two sign maintenance jobs deferred to the end of 2027 at 1:40:43, five laborers at 2:30:19. Quotations from this site's speech-to-text of the recording, checked against the video.

  5. Troy City Council Finance Committee budget hearing, October 15, 2026 — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    The mayor introduces the new deputy comptroller, "with us for three weeks," at 0:14:18. The hiring pause and "a case-by-case basis" at 0:19:43. A council member on the deputy comptroller's pay, "over a hundred thousand dollars," at 1:32:52. The mayor on "the right fit" at 1:47:21. Quotations from this site's speech-to-text of the recording, checked against the video.

  6. Troy City Council Law, Science and Technology budget hearing, October 22, 2026 — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    The full-time deputy corporation counsel job is "deferred through December 31st of 2027" at 0:48:19 to 0:48:50. Comptroller Michael McNeff on the deputy comptroller, "we did just recently hire," at 1:37:17. Quotations from this site's speech-to-text of the recording, checked against the video.

  7. Troy City Council Planning budget hearing, November 10, 2026 — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Planning jobs "on pause" and "the right person" at 0:19:10. The $98,000 commissioner of planning salary at 0:25:37. "Just not the right person" and "we could potentially go up" at 0:27:04 to 0:27:47. Quotations from this site's speech-to-text of the recording, checked against the video.

  8. New York Civil Service Law § 61, Appointment or promotion from eligible lists — New York State Senate (retrieved November 13, 2026)
  9. City of Troy 2026 Adopted Budget — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Printed p. 30, PDF p. 35. Deputy Mayor at $100,000 recommended for 2026. The file is a scan with no text, and the figure was read from the page image.

  10. City of Troy 2024 Adopted Budget — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Deputy Mayor at $94,266.

  11. Troy council Republican appointments include family ties — Times Union (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    January 5, 2024. Reports that Maria DeBonis, reappointed City Clerk, is a cousin of Deputy Mayor Seamus Donnelly.

  12. Troy residents still seek more details regarding the proposed City Hall relocation — WAMC (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Reports that DeBonis spoke in favor of the City Hall plan and is a cousin of the deputy mayor.

  13. Troy City Council organizational meeting minutes, January 5, 2026 — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Item 4 appoints Addie K. Thompson as City Clerk.

  14. Troy Fire Department, Fire Station No. 1, RFB#26-0001 — City of Troy, on BidNet Direct (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Posted March 2026 with Maria DeBonis as the City's purchasing contact.

  15. Purchasing — City of Troy (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    Lists "Maria DeBonis, Purchasing Agent."

  16. Deputy Mayor Seamus Donnelly, Facebook post on the Proctor's walkthrough — Seamus Donnelly, Facebook (retrieved November 13, 2026)

    November 12, 2026. Thanks "Purchasing Agent Maria DeBonis" among others.

  17. Russ Reeves payroll and personnel records, records request C008798-100126 — City of Troy (retrieved October 7, 2026)

    A personnel action form signed by the mayor on December 5, 2024 records a part-time Superintendent of Public Utilities position at $50,000, effective January 1, 2025, marked "Returned from LOA." Term date May 12, 2025.